This article was about choosing the right books for a student’s instructional level, which I have heard a lot about but this article really opened my eyes to struggles that students can go through and how to help those students. As I was reading the scenario about Ms. Green’s class and Jon, I realized how often this happens and how sad it really is. I was amazed by the facts given after the scenario though. I had never really thought about it in that much depth. I realized that students who were at a lower level would take longer to read, but I never realized how much longer and exactly HOW damaging it could be. It really put it in perspective to see the actually numbers of words Jon will read and how long it will take him. The line “Not only is Jon developing a negative attitude toward reading but, with each passing month, he is falling further behind in reading skills.” also really grabbed my attention. It really made me think because we, as teachers, are supposed to be fostering a positive attitude and good reading skills. This is what I have been learning in all of my methods classes at ASU and something I know for myself to be true. When I read part of the quote by Betts, “it is imperitive that a teacher or a clinician should have some systematic means of appraising a learner’s general level of achievement. Maximum development may be expected when the learner is challenged but not frustrated,” I thought back to class. In class we learned about how to do the WRI and the IRI. This is a great tool to help discover the level that the student will not be frustrated or his instructional level. I like the idea of a book being challenging but not frustrating. This is what will help students to learn. In the article another quote by Allington reminded me of the pirate study we are doing/learning about in class. “They also need access to books that entice them, attract them to reading.” I feel that the pirate study does this magnificently. I think students would be interested in and still learn a lot from the books we are using in the pirate study. Also, just the fact of using trade books in content areas made me think of the pirate study and other things we have done in our classes in Block II. In our Social Studies class, Dr. Groce is always introducing us to trade books and showing us how they are better than the textbooks for the grade level in lots of cases. Overall, I learned a lot from reading this article and found it very useful.
-
Search It!
-
Recent Entries
- “Integrating Instructional-Level Social Studies Trade Books”
- “Shared Readings” Article
- Pirate Diary Activities – “Jake Carpenter” and “What If You Met a Pirate?”
- Pirate Unit Articles
- Brown Angels
- I LOVE “Love That Dog”
- “What’s in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet.”
- HOT Blogging
- Notebook Know-How by Aimee Buckner
- “Are we Engaging our 21st Century Learners?” Video
-
Links
- Angela Sain
- Audrey Hancock
- Betsy Rinehardt
- Buzz Word
- Casey Gill
- Cinquain Poems Lesson Plan
- Dana Currin
- Danielle Epley
- Delicious
- Dr. Frye
- Emily Kerley
- ESL Idioms
- Even More Reader's Theater
- Fern's Poetry Club on PBS
- Flat Stanley
- Heather Ensley
- Heather Heath
- Idioms
- Ivyjoy
- Jessica Mundy
- Jocelyn Jackson
- Joy Cooper
- Joyful Noise – poems for two voices being sung
- Kate Fairchild
- Lindsey Bumgarner
- Link to Trading Cards Templete
- Maggie Danner
- Maggie Hinshaw
- Marissa Ireland
- NC Kid Science
- Nicole Talley
- Quote a Day
- Reader's Theater by Aaron Shepard
- Reading Lady – Reader's Theater
- Sarah Eisenhauer
- Shelby Johnson
- Stephanie Perkins
- Thinkquest
- WordPress.com
- WordPress.org